Andersen Team
Replacing a commercial roof is a major investment that affects building safety, energy bills, tenant comfort, and long-term maintenance costs. In Kansas City—where hail, heavy summer storms, and wide seasonal temperature swings are common—making the right choices up front is especially important. Below are 10 thoughtful questions property owners and facility managers ask about commercial roof replacement, with detailed answers aimed at helping you plan, budget, and pick the right system for your building.
Look for signs that indicate system-wide failure rather than localized issues. Key indicators include: frequent recurring leaks even after repairs, widespread seam failures, membrane brittleness or extensive cracking, saturated or soft insulation (often revealed by moisture scans), chronic ponding across large areas, and when the roof is near or past its expected service life (commonly 15–30 years depending on the system). If repairs are becoming more frequent and costly, perform a lifecycle cost analysis: compare projected repair costs over the next 5–10 years to the cost of replacement plus the expected remaining life. Structural concerns (deflection, sagging) or major energy performance issues (insulation loss) also typically push the decision toward replacement. A professional roof assessment with moisture tests and core samples will give the definitive data you need to decide.
Popular commercial options include TPO, PVC, EPDM (single-ply membranes), built-up roofing (BUR), modified bitumen, metal roofing, and spray polyurethane foam (SPF). For Kansas City’s climate: 1) TPO and PVC offer good weather resistance, reflectivity (lower cooling loads), and relatively fast installation; 2) EPDM is cost-effective and durable but typically less reflective unless coated; 3) Modified bitumen and BUR are proven in low-slope applications and can be economical for layered builds; 4) Metal is excellent for durability and wind resistance on sloped commercial roofs; and 5) SPF provides seamless coverage and excellent insulation performance but requires skilled applicators and periodic recoating. Choose based on building slope, rooftop equipment, lifecycle cost (not just upfront price), energy goals (cool roof reflectivity), and local contractor expertise. In Kansas City, hail resistance and UV/heat performance are especially important considerations
Costs vary widely based on roof type, square footage, accessibility, insulation needs, structural repairs, and local labor rates. Ballpark ranges (per square foot) as of typical market conditions: EPDM or TPO: $4–$10/sf; PVC and higher-performance single-ply: $6–$12/sf; Modified bitumen/BUR: $5–$12/sf; Metal roofing (commercial, not architectural): $8–$20+/sf; SPF: $6–$14/sf. These ranges can shift depending on insulation replacement, tear-off vs overlay, slope work, and unforeseen structural fixes. For accurate budgeting, get detailed, itemized bids from at least two licensed Kansas City commercial roofers, including material specs, insulation R-value, drainage improvements, permit costs, and warranty terms. Include contingency for hidden moisture or decking repairs (commonly 10–20% of the project cost).
Project duration depends on roof size, system type, weather, and scope (full tear-off vs. overlay). Small to medium single-ply replacements can take several days to 2–3 weeks. Large warehouses or complex projects (extensive insulation replacement, rooftop equipment coordination, or structural repairs) may take multiple weeks to a few months. Planning and sequencing (scheduling around tenant operations, HVAC shutdowns, or seasonal weather windows) often determine the actual timeline. In Kansas City, plan to avoid the coldest winter weeks and the stormiest parts of the year—spring and fall are commonly preferred installation windows for predictable weather.
Permit requirements vary by jurisdiction—Kansas City (MO and KS portions), surrounding suburbs, and county governments may have different rules. Typical requirements include a building permit, possibly a separate roofing permit, and compliance with local energy or stormwater ordinances for significant changes (insulation upgrades or changes to drainage). Fire code, structural load limits, and historic district rules (if applicable) can also affect the project. Your contractor should handle permit pulls or provide documentation if you manage permits yourself. Before work starts, verify with your local building department whether inspections are required at tear-off, insulation installation, and final sign-off to avoid costly rework or project delays.
Aim for a combination of manufacturer and contractor warranties. Manufacturer warranties cover material defects and can be prorated or non-prorated; many manufacturers offer system or single-source warranties when their approved installers perform the work, which is ideal. Contractor workmanship warranties should be written (commonly 1–10 years depending on scope and contractor reputation). For higher assurance, request a manufacturer-backed system warranty that includes both materials and authorized labor. Also ask about warranty conditions and exclusions (e.g., maintenance requirements, rooftop modifications that void coverage) and get the warranty documents before signing. Proper documentation is crucial for future claims or transfers if you sell the property.
Tear-off versus overlay depends on the existing roof condition, weight limits of the building structure, and long-term strategy. A full tear-off removes saturated insulation and damaged decking, allowing installers to correct structural issues and install a complete, long-lasting system—this is the preferred choice when the existing roof shows widespread problems or when you want the maximum lifespan from the new system. Overlays (recovering) add a new membrane over the existing roof and can save time and money initially but may trap moisture, add weight, and shorten the new membrane’s effective life. Many manufacturers limit or void warranties on overlay installs. For Kansas City’s climate—where moisture, freeze-thaw, and hail are concerns—tear-off is often the more prudent long-term approach unless the existing assembly is in demonstrably good condition and an overlay is explicitly supported by the manufacturer and structural engineer.
A well-planned replacement can significantly improve energy efficiency. Actions that yield measurable savings include installing higher R-value insulation, selecting reflective (cool) roof membranes or coatings to reduce summer heat gain, ensuring continuous insulation and eliminating thermal bridging at roof edges and curbs, and improving roof air/vapor barriers to prevent conditioned air loss. For many commercial buildings in Kansas City, combining increased insulation with a reflective membrane lowers summer HVAC loads and creates a more comfortable interior—often producing a clear payback when energy savings plus maintenance savings are considered. Request an energy-performance estimate from your contractor or an energy auditor to model potential savings and payback.
Select contractors using objective criteria: 1) Verify commercial licenses, bonding, and up-to-date insurance (commercial liability and workers’ comp); 2) Prefer local contractors with proven Kansas City references and a track record on similar systems; 3) Request detailed, itemized proposals including tear-off depth, insulation specs, membrane manufacturer and model, flashing details, and project schedule; 4) Ask for manufacturer-approved installer status when seeking long-term warranties; 5) Check references and recent project photos; and 6) Evaluate communication, safety program, site logistics, and cleanup plans. Avoid choosing solely on lowest price—consider lifecycle cost, warranty quality, and the contractor’s ability to coordinate with tenants, inspectors, and other trades. A solid contract with clear milestones and payment schedule protects both parties.
After replacement, implement a written maintenance plan to maximize lifespan: 1) Schedule biannual inspections (spring and fall) and post-storm checks; 2) Clean drains, scuppers, and gutters regularly to prevent ponding; 3) Inspect and maintain flashings, roof penetrations, and rooftop equipment mounts; 4) Repair small defects promptly and document all maintenance with photos and reports; 5) Plan periodic contractor-led maintenance (manufacturer-recommended recoats for SPF or reflective coatings when applicable); and 6) Keep warranty documentation, maintenance records, and contact information for the installing contractor and manufacturer. A proactive maintenance program preserves warranty validity, reduces emergency repair costs, and extends the roof’s useful life—protecting the capital investment you just made.
Need help with your project?
More Info
